Please, get rid of the replay spam. Who cares who voted or changed their minds on a replay. I rather see the after goal chat that gets missed in all the replay spam. The old replay count was ok - it let players know what the majority wants. If they want to go with the flow, they click. If they want to see it, they don't.
I see people getting bashed if the want to see a replay and don't click. With the counter, it's wasn't personal. Now it's becoming so, because some bad apples now know who didn't click.
Newbies may want to learn off a replay. Let them learn wihout being double bashed for not clicking.
Replay spam
Moderators: Jay2k1, DavidM, The_One
Some replays I want to see, so I don't mind the 100%. It works good for learning players. If for example, a new player doesn't understand how they got beat - they may want to see it so they can learn from it. If you go with majority, make it least overwhemming 75- 80%. Otherwise, the little guy won't stand much of a chance.
It seem, the more skilled a player, the less they want to see replays. Since I view replays as a learning tool, I think the 100% is benificial to deathball even though some, even if it's the majority, don't like them. I think 50% majority would mean very few replays ever, and that equals frustrated players who can't view and thus understand how they are getting beat. For replays, I think the few or one, outway the many.
Since the one wins , I feel free to vote. If it was majority, I wouldn't ever vote to skip unless the server was filled with skilled vets. There is too much skill diffference and the ratio of skilled to unskilled is too high.
It seem, the more skilled a player, the less they want to see replays. Since I view replays as a learning tool, I think the 100% is benificial to deathball even though some, even if it's the majority, don't like them. I think 50% majority would mean very few replays ever, and that equals frustrated players who can't view and thus understand how they are getting beat. For replays, I think the few or one, outway the many.
Since the one wins , I feel free to vote. If it was majority, I wouldn't ever vote to skip unless the server was filled with skilled vets. There is too much skill diffference and the ratio of skilled to unskilled is too high.
Last edited by Twigstir on 05-06-2004 07:41, edited 1 time in total.
