Thanks for the encouragement. I honestly felt like our team had a problem getting back on defense. It always seemed to be the goalie and me versus 2-4 of their guys, and because I was new, I wasn't sure exactly who to cover.
I seemed to be torn between taking away the passing lane or taking away the shot. If I was in the passing lane, then he normally had a pretty decent shot. If I was playing the shot, he had a wide open pass to an open player for a volley.
I had to work 14.5 hours yesterday so I didn't have time to try another pickup game. I'll probably try to get in one tonight.