Page 1 of 2
Neutral spectator
Posted: 08-09-2003 19:00
by Wibble
I've been thinking about some of the problems that there have been with arguments over games etc etc....
An idea I had which could sort some of these problems out would be to try and have a neutral spectator which both teams agree on for games which are likely to be controversial. They can then act as an observer to make sure things are played fair.
Posted: 08-09-2003 19:53
by Golde[nG]un
yea i like the idea
-GoldenGun
Posted: 08-09-2003 20:23
by horus-one
why not....
Posted: 08-09-2003 22:27
by Requiem
won't work at all because u can't find neutral spectators.... this spectator gonna always behind one team or could dislike the other team
Posted: 09-09-2003 01:08
by devnull
try to use an american player that doesn`t know either team
just a thought
Posted: 09-09-2003 10:05
by J-Force
/me points at DeeZ
americans dunno any team?
Posted: 09-09-2003 11:18
by Catalyst88
Like a referee? I'd volunteer to help with that
Posted: 09-09-2003 13:44
by horus-one
what cata says
Posted: 09-09-2003 14:57
by Coffin
I think this would be a good idea and i think that there should be a pool of refs and each is designated to each game and their decision is final.
Posted: 09-09-2003 15:58
by Wibble
Requiem - tbh I think you are being a little over pessimistic about the people who play deathball. For example, I would like to think that, even though I play for AoV, I could provide impartial views on the majority of other clans games.
Posted: 12-09-2003 17:46
by LyNxiFi3d
yeh a referree who has admin rights would be easier
Posted: 14-09-2003 17:10
by BlackFlame
pick me, i dont play so im not gonna be biast, and i wouldnt do the Wh or Bk games, but it depends if FC would let me
Posted: 14-09-2003 17:59
by Requiem
Wibble wrote:
Requiem - tbh I think you are being a little over pessimistic about the people who play deathball. For example, I would like to think that, even though I play for AoV, I could provide impartial views on the majority of other clans games.
i just noticed the friendly atmosphear between teams in general *cough* especially in div 1 where everyone try to get Def Win
i know some peeps could be totally neutral, but i also know some would be everything but neutral and i don't wanna see flaming on admin chan because a team gonna accuse the neutral man to giva an advantage for the others
so, i don't like this idea, just my opinion
Posted: 14-09-2003 19:26
by Wibble
Thats why the person who was chosen would have to be agreed between the two teams before the game
Posted: 14-09-2003 23:45
by BlackFlame
but i do see requeims point, that if say i was refereing a DEUS mach i may be biased towards them as my brother use to be in DEUS and i get along with DEUS really well